Saturday, December 6, 2008

Western Myth vs. Reality



During the 1870s, the myth of the cowboy fueled Western romanticism and encouraged expansion. Cowboys were idealized as noble men who upheld the virtue of goodness. However, the lives of cattle herders were not pleasant. This job required more physical labor than actual heroic duels or gunfights. In the Western "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly", the standoff starring Clint Eastwood is highly dramatized. He is portrayed as a valiant man defending his share of hidden Confederate gold. Again, the reality of being a poorly paid cowboy did not include searching for diversions in the form of buried gold or gunfights.

The reason this particular Western myth lives today is because it is a part of American culture. Towards the end of the 19th century, cities in the East were becoming increasingly industrial. Many people began to look to the West as an untouched land brimming with opportunity. Migration to the West grew because people were eager to begin their own enterprises. As a result, the "natural man", or cowboy, became a symbol of the better life people thought was available in this region.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I agree that the reason the Western myth lives is because it is a part of American culture, and that the cowboy showed the "better life" side of the West.

moyararah!!!!!!! said...

i do agree with Sara. cowboys were not just pretty boys, their jobs did require more physical labor. Also the reason why this myth lives is it is because of the American culture.

Madeline Oxendine said...

I liked that you pointed out that cowboys didn't just ride around on their horses all day, they also had to do hard labor. I also like that you included the video clip too.